maplemountains

never let the truth get in the way of a good story

Posted by: maplemountains on: August 6, 2009

In today’s Sydney Morning Herald, Jonathan Holmes, presenter of Media Watch on ABC, shamelessly announces the media’s tendency towards stretches or sometimes outright disregards of the truth in his article ‘The media: love, fear, rage and jealousy…but light on reality’.

He admits that in a time of staff cut backs, where journalists are pressed to deliver a story now, and above all sell those stories, the responsibility of good old scrupulous investigation is being wearied.

I want to place emphasis on story as Jonathan Holmes did. Story represents a piece of writing or media which can provide information, thought and above all entertainment for the audience. This element of journalism was discussed in this week’s lecture, in which facts are used as part of a story. The story must have entertainment value but nonetheless be based upon some form of factual evidence. Factual evidence is also run in counter to other pieces of fact, and so builds a nice story involving controversy, polemic and drama. As journalists it is important to substantiate your facts through diligent research and a wide range of sources, which as stated above is sometimes overlooked when time is pressing.

So, I guess it is up to the audience to maintain a sense of personal integrity towards what the media claims to be true. It is not so much about being passive and soaking up their every word as if it stemmed from some overarching authority of truth and reality. It is more about reading from a wide range of sources; from scientific journals (when scientific fact is an element, such as climate change), to newspapers, to online blog sites and documentaries. For we live in a world hungry for information, where it is a only a matter of sourcing out the good from the bad.

Advertisement

2 Responses to "never let the truth get in the way of a good story"

This is great going into next weeks lecture. I wonder if there has really been a shift in the ethical responsibility of journalism (as an industry and practice) or the fact that we now have alternatives and a proliferation of voices throws the economies of authority and attention upon which the claim to truth depends has now been substantially eroded. I guess I’m interested in the way that perhaps new media doesn’t simply erode the market which sustained high quality journalism (the dominant arguments leveled by journalists and industry leaders alike) but undermines the economies of attention, its narratives, its mode of engagement, and its economy in really monetary terms. I guess the two are related and feed(back) into each other…

That’s fair enough. But, I am too busy to keep the media accountable for their actions, I just want quick and easy information (infortainment??). I, like the ‘public trust the media to provide me with the news/current affairs. Le’t us be frank, we have 2 national papers the- Australian Financial Review and the The Australian. In Sydney the Daily Telegraph and SMH (now think about Free To Air TV). I won’t go into the empirical studies of these, but there is one more point that I would like to raise, and that is in regards to the plethora of media that some claim we have, how many of those are just repeats, and reliable…? A good case where reliability and plagarism has been put in action is the ABC’s ‘Media Watch’ court case (on their ‘lazy journalism approach,’ which is questionable since they had used material from a BBC Documentary) back in the year 2000 (vs Channel 9′s- 60 minutes).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


  • nicky88: That's fair enough. But, I am too busy to keep the media accountable for their actions, I just want quick and easy information (infortainment??). I, l
  • matws: This is great going into next weeks lecture. I wonder if there has really been a shift in the ethical responsibility of journalism (as an industry and
  • Eleni V: KB! Hectic. Blog. I know it has only begun, but your life story so far is intriguing. Jealous muchly. And what is also hectic is that i'm actuall

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.